Interactions with artificial intelligence (AI) will become an increasingly common aspect of our lives. A team at the Technical University of Munich (TUM); but has now completed the first study of how “embodied AI” can help treat mental illness. Their conclusion: Important ethical questions of this technology remain unanswered. There is urgent need for action on the part of governments, professional associations and researchers.
Robot dolls that teach autistic children to communicate better, computer-generated avatars; that help patients cope with hallucinations, and virtual chats offering support with depression; Numerous initiatives using embodied AI for improving mental health already exist. These applications are referring to as embodied; because they involve interactions; between individuals and an artificial agent, resulting in entirely new dynamics.
Genuine therapeutic statements
The use of AI in psychotherapy is not new as such. Back in the 1960s, the first chatbots created the illusion of a psychotherapy session. In reality, however, this was little more than a gimmick. With today’s advanced algorithms and higher computing power, much more is possible.
“The algorithms behind these new applications training with enormous data sets; and can produce genuine therapeutic statements,” explains Alena Buyx; Professor of Ethics in Medicine and Health Technologies at TUM. With Dr. Amelia Fiske and Peter Henningsen, Professor of Psychosomatic Medicine and psychotherapy, she has conducted the first systematic survey of embodied AI applications for mental health and drawn conclusions on the related opportunities and challenges.
Access to treatment for more people
The new applications have enormous potential. They can make treatment accessible to more people; because they are not limiting to specific times or locations. In addition, some patients find it easier to interact with AI than with a human being. But there are risks, too. “AI methods cannot and must not be using as a cheaper substitute; for treatment by human doctors,” says Amelia Fiske.
“Although embodied AI has arrived in the clinical world, there are still very few recommendations; from medical associations on how to deal with this issue. Urgent action is needed, however, if the benefits of these technologies are to be exploited while avoiding disadvantages and ensuring that reasonable checks are in place. Young doctors should also be exposed to this topic while still at medical school,” says Peter Henningsen, who is the dean of the TUM School of Medicine.
Ethical rules for artificial intelligence still lacking
At present, there are increased efforts to draw up guidelines for AI, including the Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy AI just issued by the EU. However, Buyx, Fiske and Henningsen also see an urgent need to regulate the use of AI in specialized fields. “Therapeutic AI applications are medical products for which we need appropriate approval processes and ethical guidelines,” says Alena Buyx. “For example, if the programs can recognize whether patients are having suicidal thoughts, then they must follow clear warning protocols, just like therapists do, in case of serious concerns.”
In addition, intensive study is needed into the social effects of embodied AI. “We have very little information on how we as human beings are affected by contact with therapeutic AI,” says Alena Buyx. “For example, through contact with a robot, a child with a disorder on the autism spectrum might only learn how to interact better with robots—but not with people.”